Thursday, September 20, 2012

Olive Garden Portobello Mushrooms with Mozzarella

     Since my last attempt at baking stuffed mushrooms in my dutch oven resulted in them floating in a sea of liquid, I thought I'd give them another go, this time using the larger portobello variety.  This recipe from the Olive Garden calls for baking the mushrooms, gill side down, before turning them over and adding the stuffing.  At this point I was able to drain off the excess moisture before spooning on the filling.  You can also bake them on a rack which would keep them high and dry above any liquid they exude.  They took 25 minutes to bake in my 12 inch dutch oven with 12 coals in a ring around the bottom and 24 on the lid.  Use pearl sized fresh mozzarella if you can find it, it makes the preparation that much easier.  Serve them as an appetizer or like the portobello sandwich at the Cheesecake Factory, in a hamburger bun, they're so meaty and filling you'll never miss the beef.

Olive Garden Portobello Mushrooms with Mozzarella
6 large portobello mushroom caps, stems and gills removed
2 Tblsp olive oil
2 Tblsp balsamic vinegar
8 oz. fresh mozzarella cheese cut into 1/2 inch cubes
1/4 cup roasted red bell pepper OR sun dried tomatoes, chopped
1/4 cup black olives, chopped
4 Tblsp pesto
salt and pepper to taste
*note: Italian Dressing can be used in place of olive oil and balsamic vinegar

     Lightly oil or spray dutch oven.
     Clean the mushroom caps thoroughly, use a damp towel to remove any dirt.
     Sprinkle the oil and balsamic vinegar over the mushroom caps; let caps marinate for an hour.
     In medium bowl combine mozzarella, red pepper, olives, pesto, salt and pepper; mix well.
     Remove the caps from the marinade and lay them, top side up, in prepared dutch oven.
     Bake at 375 degrees for 10-15 minutes.
     Using an oven mitt, drain excess liquid from dutch oven.
     Using tongs, turn mushrooms over.
     Fill each cap with the stuffing mixture.
     Bake for 10 minutes or until cheese has melted.
     Serve while warm.

Place mushrooms gill side down in prepared dutch oven

Bake at 375 degrees for 10-15 minutes

Drain off excess liquid and fill mushrooms with stuffing

Makes a great veggie burger or filling appetizer


  1. Those look really Good! Gunna try those soon...I use round bakers racks in mine, if I need to raise it up higher I just place canning jar rings under the rack, seems to work out fine. :-)

  2. Good idea on the rack Dale, these are really good, warmed up the leftovers in the microwave and ate them as a sandwich in a toasted English Muffin, quite tasty. Liddy

  3. Terrific! Made me look like an "expert" and I'll cook this baby over and over again. Getting six large 'rooms into a 12" wasn't possible unless stacked. No matter this is a winner!

  4. That's great Bob, so glad you found a recipe here that you like, I'd eat one of these in place of a burger any day. Thanks for letting me know, Liddy

  5. Made this last night for a couple coming over to the house for "poo poos". Goes well with a lot of cold Sangria (but doesn't everything?)
    I bought Portabellas that were too large and had to overlap a bit in the 12". This is a good excuse to purchase a larger 14" if I ever knew one, but my better half has one hand on her hip, and another with a rolling pin pointed in my direction. I will have to hold my materialism in abeyance for now....
    Excellent, quick recipe with an exotic result that pleased everyone. Thanks, Liddy!

    1. You're really on a roll Frenchy, so glad to hear everyone enjoyed the recipe. Where you do so much outdoor cooking and entertaining a larger oven would probably come in handy, I found a 14 inch Camp Chef a couple of years ago on Amazon for 25.00 so keep your eyes peeled for a bargain, they do crop up every once in a while. Happy Cooking! Liddy

  6. Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.. comprar aceite ecológico

  7. Great survey, I'm sure you're getting a great response. Shroom chocolate bars